Published: September 30, 2006 12:19 am print this story email this story comment on this story
Simpson enters not guilty plea
Gun with homemade silencer suspected as murder weapon
By KENNETH HART
The Independent
CATLETTSBURG — Authorities believe an Ashland man arrested last week for the February murder of a Flatwoods woman shot the victim with a 9 mm handgun fitted with a silencer fashioned from a plastic soft-drink bottle.
Boyd Commonwealth’s Attorney J. Stewart Schneider showed a photograph of the weapon Friday at an arraignment and bond reduction hearing for Timothy Scott Simpson.
Simpson, 23, is accused in the shooting death of 28-year-old Faith Kristen Fields Clay. Clay, who died of a gunshot wound to the head, was found Feb. 16 on a couch in Simpson’s garage apartment in the 4800 block of Boyd Street.
Police initially were not sure whether the shooting was a homicide, suicide or accident. However, investigators with the Ashland Police Department later said they suspected foul play. Simpson was ultimately revealed to be the “person of interest” police focused on following the shooting.
Simpson was arrested Sept. 21 after a Boyd County grand jury returned an indictment charging him with murder and tampering with evidence. Through his attorney, Michael Curtis of Ashland, he pleaded not guilty to the charges Friday.
Simpson’s bond was initially set at $50,000, but Circuit Judge C. David Hagerman later raised it to $250,000. Curtis requested Hagerman reinstate the original bond, saying his client wasn’t a flight risk and posed no threat to the community.
Curtis also said he and prosecutors had begun the process of discovery, or exchanging evidence, and the evidence he had received so far was “more good than bad” in favor of his client.
Also, Curtis noted gunshot residue tests performed on Simpson by police after the shooting turned out negative. However, Schneider countered that semi-automatic handguns, such as the one Simpson allegedly shot Clay with, did not ordinarily leave residue.
“We’re just about out of the GSR (gunshot residue business)” where those types of weapons are concerned, he said.
Schneider opposed Curtis’ motion to lower Simpson’s bond to its original amount. He said that in interviews with investigators, Simpson had admitted to firing the silenced pistol outside his apartment in prior to Clay’s shooting, “which is a bad idea to begin with.”
Schneider told the judge he thought a bond “somewhere in between the two figures” would be appropriate.
Hagerman said he was concerned about Simpson’s criminal record, which he said indicated a history of substance abuse and included an arrest in August for public intoxication.
“You know the saying — alcohol and firearms don’t mix,” Hagerman said.
Curtis told the judge there were no firearms in his client’s residence.
Hagerman ultimately reduced Simpson’s bond to $100,000 cash or $200,000 property.
Police have not released specific details, including a motive in the case, saying they could not do so because the seven-month-long investigation was still open.